Thursday, 22 January 2015

A French Review of Haywood's The Rash Resolve (1724)

The following very short review is of Emanuella, a French translation of Haywood’s The Rash Resolve, which appears in the Bibliothèque Française 9 (Nivôse An 9 [December 1800–January 1801]): 190–91 (here). It seems that the review is by the blind "homme de lettres" [man of letters] Marie Charles Joseph de Pougens (1755–1833)—he has a (French) Wikipedia page here—since it appears in a section titled "Notices par Charles Pougens" (ibid., 171). This review is not mentioned in my Bibliography of Eliza Haywood (under Ab.9.2).

* * * * *

Emanuella, ou la découverte prématurée. par mad. Elise Haywood. Trad. de l’Anglais. I v. in-12 de 264 p., fig. Ouvrier, rue St.-André-des-Arcs, no. 41.
  Des aventures simples, un style naturel, tels sont les principaux caractères de ce roman, dont la lecture plaira à tous ceux qui aiment à n’être que doucement intéressés.

[Emanuella, or The Premature Discovery. By Madam Elise Haywood. Translated from the English. 1 vol., 12mo. …
  Simple adventures and natural style, these are the principle characteristics of the novel, the reading of which will appeal to those who like to be only mildly engaged.]

For for a complete list of reviews of Eliza Haywood's works—including works in translation, such as this—see here.

[UPDATED 7 June 2026]

Sunday, 18 January 2015

The Betsy Thoughtless Stockmarket

The first book by Eliza Haywood that I purchased was the Pandora edition of Betsy Thoughtless (1986). I bought it on 9 December 1991 for $10. I don't know how many copies of Betsy Thoughtless I have bought since then, but it would be a lot, and all of them would have cost me more than $10. Some of them, a lot more than $10. So, although my copy of Betsy Thoughtless has great sentimental value to me, I have always considered it to be the least valuable of the lot. But no more!

Last Wednesday I was doing a search on AddAll and discovered that an extremely reliable bookseller who is offering a copy for $458 (USD364.37). My battered old copy of Betsy Thoughtless is doubling in value every four years! Unfortunately, when I look again this morning, it is clear that there has been a market correction. Sensible investors who had multiple copies have clearly been selling into this rising market and the price has fallen back to $149 (USD119.12). Those of you who have invested heavily in copies of the Pandora edition of Betsy Thoughtless can follow the value of your investment on Biblio here or ABE here.



It is always pleasing to find an extremely reliable bookseller, and so I wanted to know more about the vendor, who is called "ExtremelyReliable"—an extremely helpful choice of name, since it makes it extremely easy to remember. I pretty quickly found a page on the Zubal books site titled Never Buy Books From ... BOOKJACKERS which includes ExtremelyReliable in a list of forty bookjackers.

A bookjacker is someone who takes a genuine online listing for a book, then re-post the listing at an inflated price somewhere else. They might take a listing from Amazon, and post it on ABE.com, or from Half.com, and put it on Amazon, or eBay, or somewhere else. If a reader is foolish enough to buy from the bookjacker, the bookjacker buys the book from the original seller, providing them with the address of the actual reader. The bookjacker never sees or handles the book, but they collect their margin. Bookjacker work on a vast scale and make a lot of money from people who don't shop around, and don't suspect the practice. If you don't want to pay this tax on laziness or ignorance, don't buy from bookjacker! (Zubal explains how to avoid them.)

(Of course, a more polite form of bookjacking is as old as bookselling. Dealers buy from each other. They do it all the time, and there is a well-established, standard 10% discount offered by dealers to each another. Dealers who do not offer this discount (like—apparently—the Berkelouws), are considered arseholes by the rest of the trade. Specialist dealers obtain their stock almost exclusively in this way. At almost every book fair, dealers trawl each other's stock for any bargain (an oversight in pricing) or for stock in their specialist area: sometimes a special time is set aside before a fair opens to the public, to make sure that dealers get all the bargains. They then inflate their prices to cover their costs. This is one of the reasons specialist dealers charge more: they have to do so to cover the cost of obtaining stock. A book may change hands among dealers, many times, before a collector gets a chance to purchase it, each dealer collecting their margin like the bookjackers. The internet did not changed this method in any essential way: the specialist dealer now buys from a larger number of general dealers—whether amateur or professional—but they are still making money out of a buyer's laziness or ignorance, or by profiting from restrictive trade practices.)

Returning to the Pandora edition of Betsy Thoughtless (1986): bookjacking is only half of the explanation for the ExtremelyReliable price of USD364.37. The other half is dealers—huge ones, with a vast amounts of stock (some of them charities)—who use software to price their books. The prices are regularly updated. The software uses an algorithm to match a book to online listings (via an ISBN), establish the existing market price for that book, then undercut it by a small margin, so that their copy is neither a bargain, nor the most expensive copy online.

Bring these two dealers together and this is what happens: McDealer offers a book at $100, bookjacker relists it at $110, McDealer relists it at $105, bookjacker relists it at $115, McDealer relists it at $110, bookjacker relists it at $125, McDealer relists it at $120, and so on. This is why the price of the Pandora edition of Betsy Thoughtless wanders up and down, all on its own.

Zubal links to a very entertaining page on Amazon’s $23,698,655.93 book about flies. I went looking and found a book for USD759 billion, on Religious Plurality in Africa. (The vendor is not on Zubal's list.)


If looking for insanely-priced books is your idea of a good time, this is how you do it: go to the Amazon, Advanced Search page for books here, enter the publication date as After 1450, and Sort Results by Price: High to Low. For some reason this search doesn't work when I add Haywood as an author, but this search for Eliza Haywood on ABE (paperbacks, 1915–2015, sans print-on-demand) will help you track the value of your thirty-year old paperbacks. (Today's winner is the 1997 Oxford University Press edition of Betsy Thoughtless—another book I have! Winning again!) [For more on the Pandora edition of Betsy Thoughtless (1986) and Pandora's "Mothers of the Novel" series, see my post here]

Saturday, 17 January 2015

Early Criticism on Eliza Haywood

Thanks to Google Books, the Internet Archive and the scanning projects of various libraries, a lot of early (i.e., out-of-copyright) critical material—apart from reviews—is now available online. In the case of Eliza Haywood this is a mixed blessing, because a good deal of this material is "critical" only in the sense that it is censorious, not analytical.

However, whether adverse and positive, I think it might be useful to have such links to such criticism and comment, however brief, in one place. Unlike some of my other lists (links below), it is likely to be quite some time before this list is even close to representative or complete, but I'll start small, and add items as I find them.

[For editions of works by Eliza Haywood and recent criticism of the same, see here; for contemporary and early reviews of works by Haywood, see here; for contemporary biographical sources for Haywood, see here. For William Hatchett links see here.]

* * * * *

1832. John Genet, Some Account of the English Stage from 1660 to 1830 (Bath: H. E. Carrington for Thomas Rodd, 1832), 10 vols. ¶ Wikipedia entry here ("accurate and well-researched"); one of the more important and detailed nineteenth-century accounts of the plays by Haywood and Hatchett, frequently cited. (O = Oxford University; CaOTU = University of Toronto; * = miscataloged and not viewable outside the US.)
vol.1: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.2: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.3: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.4: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.5: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.6: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.7: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.8: O copy here* and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.9: O copy here and here; CaOTU copy here.
vol.10: O copy here and here CaOTU copy here.

Thursday, 15 January 2015

Southey's Ballad on The Witch of Berkeley, 1799

The third thread in the history of my page from Nuremberg Chronicle (1493) involves Robert Southey (1774–1843). (See here and here for my previous posts.) In 1778, Southey wrote "A Ballad. Shewing how an old woman rode double, and who rode before her." The ballad—based on William of Malmesbury's story—appears in Poems By Robert Southey, The Second Volume (Bristol: Biggs and Cottle for T. N. Longman, 1799), 143–60 (Pennsylvania State University copy, here).

Southey mentions his ballad in a letter to Charles Watkin Williams Wynn (17 December 1798; see here):

I mentioned to [Joseph] Cottle what [Mathew] Lewis wished about my Ballads,* for the copyright is his. He referred it entirely to me, but seemed convinced that to let them be printed elsewhere would injure the sale materially. I thought so too, so he must not have the Old Woman [i.e., the ballad]. In my next I will send you the wood cut, the Devil is done as well as if the Pious Painter had made the drawing from the life.

*seemingly, that Lewis wanted Southey's "Ballad" to appear in his Tales of Wonder, which it did! See Tales of Wonder (1801), 1.164–74 (Harvard University copy here).


The woodcut that Southey mentions in his letter was reproduced in his Poems (it is not clear who the artist was who copied the image. As you can see above, at bottom left, the image is signed "M [and] W Fecit") and appears at the start of his ballad, followed by a lengthy quote, in Latin, from Roger of Wendover, "De quadam muliere sortilega, et ejus miserabili morte" [Of a certain witch, and her miserable death]—for which, see my first post here. Southey mis-ascribes the Latin to the mythical Mathew of Westminster, then comments: "This story is also related by Olaus Magnus, and in the Nuremberg Chronicle, from which the wooden cut is taken"

* * * * *

Although Southey was Poet Laureate for thirty years, he is not very highly regarded and his ballad—which is certainly entertaining—seems to have attracted little attention from critics. The attention that Southey does receive today is often negative. Wikipedia attempts to gloss over his conservative toadying, but it is impossible to ignore his wrong-headedness. In the same letter quoted above, Southey describes Coleridge's "The Rime of the Ancyent Marinere"—a ballad infinitely better than his own—as "nonsense". And he famously advised Charlotte Brontë that "Literature cannot be the business of a woman's life."

Christopher J. P. Smith A Quest for Home: Reading Robert Southey (1997), 289–92 (here) contains a few pages of discussion on this ballad. Smith, disregarding Southey's own statement, mis-describes his ballad as an "adaptation of a story from Olaus Magnus" and then mis-represents it as "another supernatural revenge, a fashionable abduction story, like … Lenore of Bürger" (289). Smith concludes his helpful discussion by noting that Southey's "The Surgeon's Warning" is a parody of this "lively, episodic tale" (292), from which, it seems, Southey didn't take his own ballad too seriously. And probably didn't expect his readers to do so either.

* * * * *


Shewing How An Old Woman Rode Double,
And Who Rode Before Her.


The Raven croak'd as she sate at her meal,
  And the Old Woman knew what he said,
And she grew pale at the Raven's tale,
  And sicken'd and went to her bed.

Now fetch me my children, and fetch them with speed.
  The Old Woman of Berkeley said,
The monk my son, and my daughter the nun
  Bid them hasten or I shall be dead.

The monk her son, and her daughter the nun,
  Their way to Berkeley went,
And they have brought with pious thought
  The holy sacrament.

The old Woman shriek'd as they entered her door,
  Twas fearful her shrieks to hear,
Now take the sacrament away
  For mercy, my children dear!

Her lip it trembled with agony,
  The sweat ran down her brow,
I have tortures in store for evermore,
  Oh! spare me my children now!

Away they sent the sacrament,
  The fit it left her weak,
She look'd at her children with ghastly eyes
  And faintly struggled to speak.

All kind of sin I have rioted in
  And the judgment now must be,
But I secured my childrens souls,
  Oh! pray my children for me.

I have suck'd the breath of sleeping babes,
  The fiends have been my slaves,
I have nointed myself with infants fat,
  And feasted on rifled graves.

And the fiend will fetch me now in fire
  My witchcrafts to atone,
And I who have rifled the dead man's grave
  Shall never have rest in my own.

Bless I intreat my winding sheet
  My children I beg of you!
And with holy water sprinkle my shroud
  And sprinkle my coffin too.

And let me be chain'd in my coffin of stone
  And fasten it strong I implore
With iron bars, and let it be chain'd
  With three chains to the church floor.

And bless the chains and sprinkle them,
  And let fifty priests stand round,
Who night and day the mass may say
  Where I lie on the ground.

And let fifty choristers be there
  The funeral dirge to sing,
Who day and night by the taper's light
  Their aid to me may bring.

Let the church bells all both great and small
  Be toll'd by night and day,
To drive from thence the fiends who come
  To bear my corpse away.

And ever have the church door barr'd
  After the even song,
And I beseech you children dear
  Let the bars and bolts be strong.

And let this be three days and nights
  My wretched corpse to save,
Preserve me so long from the fiendish throng
  And then I may rest in my grave.

The Old Woman of Berkeley laid her down
  And her eyes grew deadly dim,
Short came her breath and the struggle of death
  Did loosen every limb.

They blest the old woman's winding sheet
  With rites and prayers as due,
With holy water they sprinkled her shroud
  And they sprinkled her coffin too.

And they chain'd her in her coffin of stone
  And with iron barr'd it down,
And in the church with three strong chains
  They chain'd it to the ground.

And they blest the chains and sprinkled them,
  And fifty priests stood round,
By night and day the mass to say
  Where she lay on the ground.

And fifty choristers were there
  To sing the funeral song,
And a hallowed taper blazed in the hand
  Of all the sacred throng.

To see the priests and choristers
  It was a goodly sight,
Each holding, as it were a staff,
  A taper burning bright.

And the church bells all both great and small
  Did toll so loud and long,
And they have barr'd the church door hard
  After the even song.

And the first night the taper's light
  Burnt steadily and clear,
But they without a hideous rout
  Of angry fiends could hear;

A hideous roar at the church door
  Like a long thunder peal,
And the priests they pray'd and the choristers sung
  Louder in fearful zeal.

Loud toll'd the bell, the priests pray'd well,
  The tapers they burnt bright,
The monk her son, and her daughter the nun
  They told their beads all night.

The cock he crew, away they flew
  The fiends from the herald of day,
And undisturb'd the choristers sing
  And the fifty priests they pray.

The second night the taper's light
  Burnt dismally and blue,
And every one saw his neighbour's face   
  Like a dead man's face to view.

And yells and cries without arise
  That the stoutest heart might shock,
And a deafening roaring like a cataract pouring
  Over a mountain rock.   

The monk and nun they told their beads
  As fast as they could tell,
And aye as louder grew the noise
  The faster went the bell.

Louder and louder the choristers sung
  As they trembled more and more,
And the fifty priests prayed to heaven for aid,
  They never had prayed so before.

The cock he crew, away they flew
  The fiends from the herald of day,
And undisturb'd the choristers sing
  And the fifty priests they pray.

The third night came and the tapers flame
  A hideous stench did make,
And they burnt as though they had been dipt
  In the burning brimstone lake.

And the loud commotion, like the rushing of ocean.
  Grew momently more and more,
And strokes as of a battering ram
  Did shake the strong church door.

The bellmen they for very fear
  Could toll the bell no longer,
And still as louder grew the strokes
  Their fear it grew the stronger.

The monk and nun forgot their beads,
  They fell on the ground dismay'd,
There was not a single saint in heaven
  Whom they did not call to aid.

And the choristers song that late was so strong
  Grew a quaver of consternation,
For the church did rock as an earthquake shock
  Uplifted its foundation.

And a sound was heard like the trumpet's blast
  That shall one day wake the dead,
The strong church door could bear no more
  And the bolts and the bars they fled.

And the taper's light was extinguish'd quite,
  And the choristers faintly sung,
And the priests dismay'd, panted and prayed
  Till fear froze every tongue.

And in He came with eyes of flame
  The Fiend to fetch the dead,
And all the church with his presence glowed
  Like a fiery furnace red.

He laid his hand on the iron chains
  And like flax they moulder'd asunder,
And the coffin lid that was barr'd so firm
  He burst with his voice of thunder.

And he bade the Old Woman of Berkeley rise
  And come with her master away,
And the cold sweat stood on the cold cold corpse,
  At the voice she was forced to obey.

She rose on her feet in her winding sheet,
  Her dead flesh quivered with fear,
And a groan like that which the Old Woman gave
  Never did mortal hear.

She followed the fiend to the church door,
  There stood a black horse there,
His breath was red like furnace smoke,
  His eyes like a meteor's glare.

The fiendish force flung her on the horse
  And he leapt up before,
And away like the lightning's speed they went
  And she was seen no more.

They saw her no more, but her cries and shrieks
  For four miles round they could hear,
And children at rest at their mother's breast,
  Started and screamed with fear.

Wednesday, 14 January 2015

De Castigatione Maleficarum; Or: The Punishment of Witches

The next thread in the history of my page from Nuremberg Chronicle (1493) involves Vincent of Beauvais [aka Vincentius Burgundus] (d. 1264?) and Olaus Magnus (d.1557). (For my first post on this page, see here.)

Vincent of Beauvais was an encyclopaedist. His vast Speculum Maius [Great Mirror] (1244) is in three parts, one of which is the still-enormous Speculum Historiale [Mirror of History]. I have not been able to find online a copy of the relevant parts of the Speculum Historiale, but Olaus Magnus quotes William of Malmesbury's 1125 story concerning "a certain wicked woman" via Vincent of Beauvais in his Historia de Gentibus Septentrionalibus [History of the Northern Peoples] (1555), Book 3, ch.21.

(Book 3 of the Historia is on the subject of "De superstitiosa cultura dæmonum populorum Aquilonarium" [The superstitious worship of demons by the Scandinavians or Popular superstitions and demon worship of the Scandinavians], chapter 21 is on "De castigatione maleficarum" [the punishment of witches or, the castigation of malefactors].)




As you can see above, Olaus Magnus offers the following brief introduction to the story:

Lest the Northern Witches should seem to be quoted here only as having been made sad examples of, there occurs in Vincentius's History, book 25, cap. 26, a story of an English woman, who having been baffled by the magic art, was carried into the air with horrid shouts by the Dæmons, after she had endured severe torments. The words run thus: When a certain woman living at Berkeley, a small village in England, a Fortune-teller and a Sorceress … [Vincent quotes William of Malmesbury's story]

[Ne videantur septentrionales maleficiae solum hic ad tristia spectacula adduci, occurrit Vincen. in Spe. Hist. lib. 25, cap. 26, afferens Anglicanam fœminam arte magica illusam, a Dæmonibus post dira tormenta, ad aera cum clamoribus horrendis fuisse rapta. Cujus verba hæc sunt: Mulier quædam apud Berkeleiam Angliæ villam auguratrix et malefica … etc.]

[I am indebted to Edward Athenry Whyte for both the Latin and the translation of the above passage from Olaus Magnus and Vincent of Beauvais (Whyte will be the subject of another post).]

* * * * *

Anyway, the following illustration of William of Malmesbury's story appears in the 1555 edition of Olaus Magnus' text (taken from the National Library of Norway copy here; other copies online include Ghent University copy here and Lyon Public Library copy here).


According to Jane P. Davidson, The Witch In Northern European Art, 1470–1750 (1987), 27–28:

The first edition of the Historia … is a lavish, beautifully bound and printed book which was illustrated throughout with engravings of the deeds of witches and demons. The iconography of these illustrations conforms to the descriptions in Olaus Magnus' text. … p. 126 shows a female witch being carried off by a demon who is astride an enchanted horse. Clearly this witch has met with a bad end, as she seems very reluctant to accompany the devil. She is not on her way to a sabbat, but rather to hell. The caption reads "De castigatione maleficarum."

Davidson goes on to explain that a second edition (1567) was illustrated by "the Master C.G." who, as you can see below, masterfully copied the illustrations in the first edition (1555).



Although there are other illustrated editions of Olaus Magnus' Historia, I was unable to find other online editions which illustrate this story.


* * * * *

The Historia was quickly translated into English by John Streater as: A Compendious History of the Goths, Swedes and Vandals and other Northern Nations (London: J. Streater, 1658) [Wing M257 (34 copies on ESTC here)]. Streater titles Book 3 of the Historia as The Superstitious Worship of Devils, used by the People of the North, William of Malmesbury's story appears as chapter 20 (rather than 21), and is titled The punishment for Witches (on pp.50–51).


Since Streater's translation is not available online, I will transcribe the text here:

LEST the Northern Witches should seem alone here to be led to sad spectacles, Vincentius in Spec. Hist. l. 25, c. 26, comes and tells us that an English woman, deluded by Magical Art, after cruel torments, was carryed by the Devils into the Ayr with horrid cries. His words are these:
  There was a certain Woman in Bethelia [sic], a Village in England, that was a South-sayer and a Witch who one day, when she was eating, heard her chough, that she took great pleasure in, to speak something more loud than it was wont to do: When the Mistriss heard this, her knife fell out of her hand, and she grew pale in her face; and lamenting, she said very often: This day is my Plough come to the last Furrow; this day shall I hear and receive great hurt.
  As she yet spake, a Messenger came to her, saying; This day is thy Son dead, and all thy Family died suddenly. This heard, she sank down, wounded with continual grief, and she commanded all her children that were alive to be brought to her, which were a Fryer and a Nun; to whom she sighing, said thus: I by my miserable destiny, ever was a servant to the Divel in my actions, I am the Sink of all Vice, and the Mistriss of enticements: I onely confided in your Religion, and I despaired to my self: But now, because I know the Divel shall have me to torment me, who perswaded me to offend, I beseech you, by the bowels of your Mother, that you will attempt to ease my torments; for you cannot revoke the Sentence of Damnation passed upon my soul: Werefore sow up my body in a Stags skin, and put it into a Chest of Stone, and fasten the cover with Iron and Lead, and bind about the stone with three great chains. If I ly three nights thus in safety, you shall bury me the fourth day: though I fear the Earth will not receive me, by reason of my Witchchrafts; let there be Psalms sung for me fifty nights, and Mass said for me as many dayes. They did as she bad them, but it nothing availed; for the two first nights, when the Clerks and Queristers sand Psalms about her body, all the Devils easily breaking the Church door that was fastened with a mighty bar, tore in pieces two of the chains; but the middle chain which was made stronger, held fast. The third night, about Cock-crowing, all the Monastery seemed to be lifted from the Foundation, with a noise of Enemies coming; one of them was more terrible to look on, and taller than the rest; and he striking the Church-door with great force, brake them into fritters, and came proudly to the Coffin, and in arrogant gesture, and calling her by her name, commanded her to rise. When she answered, that she could not for her bands.
  Thou shalt, saith he, be unbounded, but to thy greater mischief: And he forthwith brake the Chain, the rest of the Devils could not do, as if it had been Flax, and he kicked off the cover of the Grave with his foot; and taking her by the hand before them, he drew her forth at the Church-doors, where there was prepared a black horse, which proudly neighed, that had Hooks of Iron all over him, that stuck forth: Upon this Horse was this miserable woman set, and she presently disappeared from the beholders eyes, with all her company. But there were cryes heard almost four miles, of this miserable wretch calling for help.